Book

Bloodlands

Europe Between Hitler and Stalin

Timothy Snyder

Basic Books, 2012

Buy book or audiobook

Read offline

Amazon Kindle

We currently cannot offer you an audio version of this summary.

Editorial Rating

getAbstract synthétise des ouvrages* qui permettent aux utilisateurs de mieux comprendre le monde pour le rendre meilleur. Quel que soit le livre que nous sélectionnons pour notre bibliothèque, il doit se distinguer par l'un ou l'autre des deux critères suivants :

Enrichissant – Les enseignements que vous en tirerez orienteront et amélioreront vos décisions.

Utile – Les conseils pratiques qui sont dispensés vous aideront à améliorer la prise de décision.

Nous évaluons chaque contenu sur une échelle de 1 à 10 en fonction de ces deux qualités essentielles . La note attribuée vous permet de classer les titres de votre liste de lecture de Plaisant (5) à Excellent (10). Les livres qui obtiennent moins de 5 ne font pas l'objet d'une publication. Voici ce que signifie chaque note :

10 – Excellent. Un livre utile et/ou instructif qui, outre ses nombreuses qualités, fait office de classique du genre. Une référence.
9 – Superbe. Un livre utile et/ou instructif extrêmement bien écrit et structuré, qui présente de multiples caractéristiques positives et aucune lacune notable.
8 – Très bien. Un livre utile et/ou instructif qui présente de multiples caractéristiques positives mais quelques points faibles. L'ouvrage peut par exemple présenter les dernières découvertes dans un domaine spécialisé et être rédigé par un expert, mais pécher par son style d'écriture.
7 – Bien. Un livre utile et/ou instructif, qui combine deux ou plusieurs caractéristiques positives. Il peut par exemple contenir des idées novatrices, présentées de manière engageante.
6 – Appréciable. Un livre utile et/ou instructif, qui présente au moins un aspect engageant. Il peut, par exemple, être particulièrement bien structuré.
5 – Plaisant. Un livre utile et/ou instructif, même si le contenu pourrait être amélioré. Ce livre peut par exemple prodiguer des conseils utiles dans certains domaines, mais être répétitif et sans relief particulier.

*getAbstract synthétise bien plus que des livres. Nous recherchons tous types de contenus pouvant intéresser nos lecteurs : des livres, mais également des articles, des rapports, des vidéos et des podcasts. Nos classifications sont valables pour les livres, mais également pour les autres formats que nous proposons.

Recommendation

So much has been written about the atrocities committed in Eastern Europe during the 1930s and 1940s – not to mention all the feature films and documentaries – that casual observers of history might think they already know this story. Then along comes Yale historian Timothy Snyder, who recasts the drama of the 14 million people starved, shot and gassed during a 12-year period. Snyder precisely documents how Stalin and Hitler utilized the “bloodlands” – the borderlands between their nations – to execute their genocidal plans. Snyder’s great contribution is to “turn the numbers back into people.” getAbstract thinks his meticulous history should be required reading, particularly for new generations who may not understand the full horror or impact of Europe’s greatest murder mystery. And what is that mystery? It is not who committed the crimes or why; that is mostly known from this source and many others. Rather it is how each victim faced death, often in the most cruel circumstances, and how the killers, millions of people, and their witnesses, millions more, lived with these crimes, and even justified them.

Summary

“Bloodlands”

With the end of World War I, Europe fractured, populations dispersed and emperors gave way to elected leaders. Eastern Europe, or the bloodlands, became a buffer between Germany and the Soviet Union. The territory stretched from the Baltics south through Belarus, Poland and the Ukraine. Here in the brackish currents of ethnicity, race and tribe, Stalin and Hitler pressed their ideologies and their dreams for empire – dreams that cost the lives of 14 million people.

In 1932, Soviet collectivization and bad weather undermined food production. To meet government quotas, farmers had to surrender their seed grain, leaving them with nothing to sow for the next year. By that summer, in Kazakhstan alone, more than a million people had starved to death. Stalin saw “the starvation of Ukrainian peasants as a betrayal by members of the Ukrainian communist party.” He ordered his loyal, forceful administrators to fix the problem, but the bad times returned. In the “Soviet famines of 1933,” more than five million people starved to death, mostly in the Ukraine. Instead of benefiting from the revolution, peasants were recast as enemies of the state and divided into classes...

About the Author

Yale University history professor Timothy Snyder specializes in the Holocaust and Central and Eastern Europe.

Comment on this summary or Démarrer une discussion

Sign in to share your opinion
A. M. 4 years ago

This really is a fantastic book. The summary could do more to better and more memorably highlight the contribution of Snyder's work: Snyder analyses the entire period of mass murder during the lands between Germany and Soviet territories, from 1930-1945. This is a novel contribution to a relatively saturated field of research since these stories are told in isolation or against other narratives. Snyder cares not for sanctified stories, but rather analyses this bloody period in relation. This book gives an insight into murder and territory in the great middle: the 'Bloodlands'. Read this book!
I. P. 7 years ago

Poor non-sence.
M. S. 9 years ago

An important subject for history students and whom ever is interested in the tragic holocaust, but an importance of 10 is way over the top. With all due respect, how would a drug addict, an American homeless or an African orphan would benefit from this book? Emotions took their toll with this disappoint and unbalanced rating. This is not to belittle the events, but current tragedies deserve more attention since they can be stopped unlike the tragic holocaust where it ended with only only tears and memories left from it.

Bloodlands

Europe Between Hitler and Stalin

Read offline

Editorial Rating

Recommendation

Summary

“Bloodlands”

About the Author

My Highlights

Comment on this summary or Démarrer une discussion

More on this topic

By the same author

Learners who read this summary also read

Related Channels