Cambridge Business Association
Managing the Myths of Health Care
Book

Managing the Myths of Health Care

Bridging the Separations Between Care, Cure, Control, and Community

Henry Mintzberg
Berrett-Koehler, 2017
Buy book or audiobook

Read or listen offline

Amazon Kindle
  • 0.5×
  • 0.75×
  • 1×
  • 1.25×
  • 1.5×
  • 1.75×
1×

Editorial Rating

9

Qualities

  • Analytical
  • Applicable
  • Overview

Recommendation

Management guru Henry Mintzberg brings his contrarian, astute advice to health care. After an indictment of dysfunctional “health care systems” worldwide – particularly in the United States and Canada – he prescribes greater collaboration, less competition and more emphasis on cause over cure. From the folly of “managerial fads” to simplistic government fixes, Mintzberg argues that health care suffers from weak leadership and trendy strategy. To his way of thinking, only on-the-ground management can fix it. While health care must include specialists, he says, it should overcome the divisions among physicians, administrators and providers. Such silos reinforce entrenched hierarchies and undermine patient care. While always politically neutral, getAbstract thinks health care professionals, administrators, policy makers, politicians, patients and investors will find food for thought in Mintzberg’s analysis.

Summary

Health Care Is Not a Business

Worldwide, health care has made tremendous strides. People now live longer than ever in human history. Yet patients and their families want, expect and demand more, but they “don’t want to pay for it.” This makes cost cutting paramount, and health care systems suffer.

Leaders in government and health care administration – who seldom understand the daily work of doctors, nurses and other practitioners – implement trendy fixes under the guise of running health care “like a business.” Health care can’t focus on cost cutting – nor can it put the burdens of “caveat emptor” and “comparison shopping” on sick, sometimes dying or incapacitated patients. Society can’t let pharmaceutical giants charge “what the market will bear” for products patients need to stay alive. Nor should administrators use carrots and sticks to motivate doctors and nurses, who put up with daily tragedy and stress largely because they see their work as a “calling.” Health care can benefit from some business practices, but it can’t operate as a business.

“Collaborative Autonomy”

Administrators, governments and pharmaceuticals share only part of the blame. Physicians...

About the Author

Henry Mintzberg teaches at McGill University’s School of Management. His 19 books include Rebalancing Society, Managing, Simply Managing and Strategy Safari.

Comment on this summary

  • Avatar
    Sign in to share your opinion
  • Avatar
    A. D. 2 months ago
    Interesting, good, good
  • Avatar
    M. A. 2 months ago
    Very instructive. Thank you
  • Avatar
    A. 7 years ago
    There are interesting parallels to his view on what healthcare needs and to what I think large corporations need. And I'd be interested to see the agile method used to build ground up ways to approach healthcare. The Mayo Clinic sounds good but I bet there are even better ways waiting to be co-designed.